Athena Hogan: Forty Years Later, the Connections and Questions Remain

There was something different about growing up in the 1980s. We rode our bicycles through neighborhoods, played outside until the streetlights came on, and wandered from one friend's house to another without our parents knowing exactly where we were every minute of the day. We knocked on strangers' doors to sell candy for school fundraisers, and nobody thought much of it. It was simply part of being a kid.
I grew up in Lawton, Oklahoma, where that kind of childhood was familiar to me. We had our favorite places to play, neighborhood friends, and adults who seemed to know everybody. Looking back, I realize how much freedom we had and how little we understood about the dangers that sometimes existed around us.
On October 1, 1986, ten-year-old Athena Marie Hogan, known to her family as Tina, was doing something countless children did in those days. She was going door-to-door selling candy.
She never made it home.
Athena was abducted and murdered that evening. Her body was discovered by a man named Robert Taylor, and another man, Harvey Lee Templeton, would eventually stand trial for her murder. Templeton was acquitted in 1987, and Athena's murder remains unsolved.
I was seven years old when Athena was murdered, and my connection to her story began long before I ever picked up a court transcript. I knew Robert Taylor, the man who discovered her body, and the events surrounding Athena's murder are tied to the very first panic attack I ever experienced.
Forty years later, I'm doing something I never imagined I would do. I'm bringing Athena's story and the original court proceedings to the public through Into the Weeds Podcast. To my knowledge, Athena's case has received virtually no attention from the true crime community. Ken Mains is the only other true crime investigator I'm aware of who has covered her murder, and his involvement came about because I brought the case to his attention.
Through the preliminary hearing and subsequent trial transcripts, my daughter Alaura and I are sharing testimony and details that have largely remained outside public discussion for decades. For me, this isn't about creating another true crime series. It's about preserving the historical record, asking questions that remain unanswered, and bringing attention to a little girl whose story deserves to be heard.
A Childhood Connection I Never Forgot
Robert Taylor wasn't simply a name I encountered decades later while researching an unsolved murder. He was someone I knew through my family.
I knew his car. I knew he was part of the world surrounding my grandmother's home, and I knew people in my family had relationships with him and his younger brother, David.
One of those memories involves Robert Taylor's tan Volkswagen Beetle. I remember playing around that vehicle as a child, and as I've examined the case, I've wondered about footprints reportedly found on his car and whether any of them could have been mine.
I have no way of establishing that. It's simply a question that has stayed with me.
While reviewing the testimony and speaking with my cousin, I finally learned why Robert had been around my grandmother's neighborhood so frequently.
His family had lived approximately five doors down from her.
According to the information I've gathered from my cousin and the preliminary hearing, the Taylor family had moved from that neighborhood roughly two years before Athena's murder.
That explained something I had wondered about for years. Robert and his family weren't simply visiting people in the neighborhood. They had once been part of it.
It also raised questions about how long those friendships and relationships continued after the family moved.
At seven years old, I couldn't have understood all the relationships and circumstances surrounding Athena's murder. Reading the testimony today has given me a different perspective on people and places I remember from childhood.
Robert Taylor's Movements Before Athena's Murder
One of the details that caught my attention while examining the court transcripts concerns Robert Taylor's movements in the days leading up to Athena's murder.
According to the testimony we've been reviewing, Robert had been in Athena's neighborhood approximately one or two days before she was murdered, reportedly within a door or two of her home.
Then, on October 1, 1986, Robert testified that he dropped his younger brother, David, off at a Church of God located at 9th and Lee in Lawton.
That church was associated with Reverend Ronnie Miller Sr., whose son, Ronnie Lewis Miller Jr., had been accused of brutally beating Athena's mother, Cindy Hogan, just months earlier.
Later that same day, Robert became the man who discovered Athena's body.
When I began putting these details together, I had questions. Why had Robert been in Athena's neighborhood just days before her murder? Who was he visiting? And how did he come to be dropping his brother off at a church connected to the family of the man accused of attacking Athena's mother?
I also wondered whether investigators had explored these circumstances together or considered them separately.
None of these details establishes that Robert was involved in Athena's murder. But examining his movements in chronological order reveals connections that I believe deserve closer attention, particularly because investigators also considered whether Cindy Hogan's assault and Athena's murder might have been related.
The Investigation Into Robert Taylor
Because Robert discovered Athena's body, he was among the individual investigators examined during the early stages of the case.
According to Detective Donald Belcher's preliminary hearing testimony, Robert went to the Lawton Police Department on October 3, accompanied by his attorney, Mike Miller.
Investigators examined Robert's Volkswagen and collected items from his residence, including a sleeping bag and raincoat.
The condition of those items became a subject of questioning during the preliminary hearing. Belcher acknowledged that the sleeping bag and raincoat were damp, but testimony also raised the possibility that rainwater had entered the vehicle's trunk after police handled or returned it.
That detail illustrates something I've repeatedly encountered while examining this case: circumstances that initially sound suspicious sometimes have explanations that only become apparent when the testimony is read in context.
I think that's important to remember when examining any unsolved murder. Questions deserve to be asked, but the answers must come from evidence rather than assumptions.
Still, the testimony about Robert's movements led me to another part of Athena's story that I believe has received far too little attention: the violent assault on her mother earlier that year.
Cindy Hogan's Assault and the Miller Family Connection
Months before Athena was murdered, her mother, Cindy Hogan, suffered a devastating beating.
Her injuries left her with significant physical and communication difficulties, and she was still dealing with the consequences when her daughter disappeared.
Ronnie Lewis Miller Jr. was accused in connection with that assault. The maiming charge against him was ultimately dismissed, and he was not convicted of the offense.
This is why the church Robert visited on October 1 caught my attention. Reverend Ronnie Miller Sr., the father of the man accused of attacking Cindy, was associated with that church.
It wasn't a detail I was expecting to encounter while reading testimony about Robert Taylor's activities on the day Athena disappeared.
But the court records revealed that Cindy's assault wasn't entirely separate from the questions being asked during the murder proceedings.
During the preliminary hearing in the case against Harvey Templeton, defense attorney John Zelbst questioned Athena's aunt, Lorraine Jenkins, about Cindy's injuries.
Lorraine identified Ronnie Miller as the man accused of beating her sister. She also testified that she had previously dated Ronnie and that Cindy had identified him to a police officer before entering a coma.
Lorraine was not present when Cindy was assaulted, so her account of what Cindy reportedly told police was secondhand.
Then the defense asked whether Lorraine believed Cindy's beating and Athena's murder might have been connected.
Her answer was:
“It might. I don't know.”
What interested me about that exchange wasn't simply Lorraine's answer. It was the fact that the possibility of a connection between Cindy's assault and Athena's murder was being discussed in court nearly forty years ago.
And Lorraine wasn't the only witness questioned about it.
What Did Investigators Learn?
Detective Donald Belcher also addressed Cindy's assault during his preliminary hearing testimony.
Belcher acknowledged that he believed a man named Miller had beaten Cindy, although he admitted he hadn't personally investigated the assault.
When asked what Cindy had been beaten with, Belcher responded:
“I don't recall. I didn't check that out.”
The defense then asked whether police had attempted to determine if Cindy's beating was connected to Athena's disappearance.
Belcher replied:
“That was looked into.”
When asked who might have conducted that investigation, Belcher answered:
“I believe Detective Wells talked to Miller.”
That testimony establishes something important: investigators had considered the possibility that Cindy's assault and Athena's disappearance were connected.
But what happened next?
I haven't located separate testimony from Detective Wells in the preliminary hearing material we've examined. I don't know what questions he asked, what Miller told him, or what conclusions investigators reached. I also don't know whether investigators established Ronnie Miller's whereabouts on October 1, 1986.
Despite my attempts to obtain additional investigative records, I've been unable to access the information that might answer those questions.
I'm not suggesting that Ronnie Miller was responsible for Athena's murder. What interests me is that a possible connection between two violent crimes involving the same family was examined by investigators, yet the outcome of that inquiry remains unclear in the records available to me.
And nearly forty years later, those unanswered questions are still worth documenting.
The Case Against Harvey Templeton
As the investigation continued, attention eventually shifted toward Harvey Lee Templeton.
Templeton lived in the area where Athena had been selling candy, and investigators testified that he acknowledged Athena had visited his home that afternoon.
Detective Belcher also described Templeton's account of driving to 11th and Gore Boulevard later that evening to dispose of trash.
Investigators questioned that trip, as well as Templeton's decision to trade in his vehicle shortly after Athena's murder.
Carpet fiber evidence also became an important part of the investigation. Detectives collected samples from numerous residences and businesses in the area, including Templeton's home, and submitted evidence for forensic comparison.
The defense challenged the investigation on several fronts, including the timing of Templeton's movements and the interpretation of certain evidence.
Templeton was ultimately acquitted in July 1987.
Although he was prosecuted for Athena's murder, the jury did not find him guilty, and her case remained unresolved.
For me, reading the preliminary hearing and subsequent trial transcripts isn't about trying to retry Templeton or assign guilt to someone else. It's about understanding the evidence, the questions that were asked, and the investigative avenues that were explored.
Sometimes, it's the details surrounding those investigations that reveal how much of the story has been forgotten.
Another Unexpected Family Connection
As I've continued researching Athena's murder, I've also learned just how many connections exist between her family and mine.
One of the most unexpected involves my aunt, who married a man whose late wife was one of Athena Hogan's aunts.
That makes another connection between our families through marriage.
It has nothing to do with establishing what happened to Athena, but it reminds me how closely people's lives can intersect, sometimes without us fully understanding those connections until years later.
When I was seven years old, I never imagined I would still be examining Athena's murder forty years later. I certainly couldn't have imagined that another connection between our families would emerge along the way.
Yet here I am, looking through decades-old testimony, talking with relatives, and finding pieces of a story that has been part of my life since childhood.
The Little Girl Behind the Testimony
Sometimes, when I'm reading hundreds of pages of testimony, I have to remind myself that this story isn't really about Robert Taylor, Harvey Templeton, Ronnie Miller, or any of the other names that appear throughout the investigation.
It's about Athena.
A ten-year-old girl who went out selling candy on an ordinary October afternoon and never came home.
She should have been able to finish growing up, go to school, make friends, and experience all the ordinary moments that make up a person's life.
Instead, she became the victim of a terrible crime, and her family was left to endure an unimaginable loss.
I was a child when Athena was murdered, and I couldn't possibly have understood everything that was happening around me. But I remember the people, the places, and the feelings associated with that time.
Forty years later, I have an opportunity to revisit those events through testimony, historical records, and conversations with people who remember Lawton in 1986.
My daughter and I have spent countless hours examining the court proceedings and sharing them publicly because I believe Athena's story deserves more than to remain buried in documents that few people have ever had the opportunity to read.
I don't know whether I'll ever find the answers to all the questions I have. But I can continue documenting what the witnesses said, examining the evidence, and bringing attention to a case that has received far too little public attention.
Because behind every transcript, every police report, and every unanswered question was a little girl whose life mattered.
Her name was Athena Marie Hogan.
And forty years later, she still deserves to be remembered.
"Do something good to change the world for the better."
Into the Weeds Podcast on Military Broadcast Radio
*Research note: This article draws on preliminary hearing testimony, subsequent trial materials, and personal and family recollections. Witness statements and investigative leads are not findings of guilt. Certain details, including the outcome of the reported inquiry into a possible connection between Cindy Hogan's assault and Athena's murder, remain unverified.*


Comments